Reports of Cases
2010 I-01289
Subject-matter
Reference for a preliminary ruling – Finanzgericht Hamburg – Interpretation of the Euro-Mediterranean Agreement establishing an association between the European Communities and their Member States, of the one part, and the State of Israel, of the other part, signed at Brussels on 20 November 1995 (OJ 2000 L 147, p. 3) and in particular Articles 32 and 33 of Protocol 4 of that agreement, and of the Euro-Mediterranean Interim Association Agreement on trade and cooperation between the European Community, of the one part, and the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) for the benefit of the Palestinian Authority of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, of the other part, signed at Brussels on 24 February 1997 (OJ 1997 L 187, p. 3) – Refusal to apply the preferential tariff regime granted to goods originating in Israel to goods originating in an Israeli settlement in the West Bank – Power of the authorities of the importing State to verify subsequently the proof-of-origin certificates in the absence of doubts concerning the origin of the goods in question other than those resulting from a divergence of opinion between the parties to the EEC-Israel Association Agreement as to the interpretation of the expression ‘territory of the State of Israel’ and in the absence of previous resort, for the purposes of the interpretation of that expression, to the dispute-settlement procedure provided for under Article 33 of Protocol 4 of that agreement
Systematic classification scheme
1.
|
|
6 External policy
6.07 International agreements
6.07.15 Free trade, association, stabilisation etc. agreements
6.07.15.03 Countries outside Europe
|
|
|
6 External policy
6.07 International agreements
6.07.15 Free trade, association, stabilisation etc. agreements
6.07.15.03 Countries outside Europe
|
Citations of case-law or legislation
References in grounds of judgment
-
TFEU, Article 217
: paragraph 39
-
TFEU, Article 218
: paragraph 39
-
TFEU, Article 267
-L1LB : paragraph 39
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
: paragraph 1
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A02P2 : paragraph 25
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A03 : paragraphs 21, 48
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A05 : paragraphs 22, 48
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A06 : paragraphs 22, 48
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A15 : paragraph 57
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A15P1 : paragraph 26
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A16P1 : paragraph 27
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A16P4 : paragraphs 27, 50
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A20P1 : paragraph 26
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A20P1LA : paragraphs 28, 50
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A20P2 : paragraph 28
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A21 : paragraphs 28, 29
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A21P1 : paragraph 50
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A73 : paragraph 47
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
: paragraphs 1, 7, 41, 44, 49, 54, 58, 64, 70, 71
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A02P2 : paragraph 13
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A06P1 : paragraphs 8, 48
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A08 : paragraphs 9, 48
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A17 : paragraph 57
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A17P1 : paragraph 14
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A22P1LA : paragraphs 15, 49
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A32 : paragraphs 17, 60, 64, 68, 70, 73
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A32P6 : paragraphs 65, 67, 73
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A33 : paragraph 18
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A39 : paragraphs 19, 69, 73
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A75P1 : paragraph 10
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A83 : paragraphs 11, 45, 47, 52, 53
-
Decision 97/430
: paragraph 20
-
Decision 2000/384
: paragraph 7
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -218/83
: paragraphs 61, 62
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -12/86
: paragraph 39
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -432/92
: paragraph 57
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -162/96
: paragraphs 39, 42
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -416/96
: paragraph 42
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -268/99
: paragraph 42
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -23/04
: paragraphs 63, 72
Operative part
Opinion
-
EC Treaty (Maastricht), Article 228
: point 60
-
EC Treaty (Maastricht), Article 238
: point 60
-
EC Treaty (Maastricht), Article 177
-L1LB : point 60
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
: points 1 - 8, 12, 32, 59, 105, 106, 121 - 140
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A01P2 : point 33
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A05 : point 34
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A06 : point 34
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A67 : point 36
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-A73 : point 37
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-PR : point 32
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-PRO3A02P2LA : point 35
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-PRO3A02P2LB : point 35
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-PRO3A04 : point 35
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 21997A0716(01)
-PRO3A16P4 : point 127
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
: points 1 - 8, 12, 26, 59, 73, 86 - 140
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A07 : point 16
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A08 : point 16
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A67 : points 17, 103
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A68 : point 88
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A75 : point 87
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A75P1 : points 18, 102
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A79P2 : point 19
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-A83 : points 20, 108, 113
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PR : points 14, 15
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4 : point 22
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A02P2LA : point 21
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A02P2LB : point 21
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A04 : point 21
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A05P2LA : point 70
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A06 : point 70
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A17 : point 66
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A17P1 : point 22
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A18P1 : points 22, 66
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A18P6 : point 66
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A32 : points 23, 59, 62, 70, 96, 100, 140
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A32P1 : point 67
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A32P2 : points 59, 68
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A32P3 : points 24, 68
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A32P5 : point 68
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A32P6 : points 24, 69
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A33 : points 59, 63
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A33L1 : points 25, 97, 99
-
Agreement with Third Countries or International Bodies - 22000A0621(01)
-PRO4A05 : point 21
-
Regulation 2840/72
: point 73
-
Regulation 1246/73
-N : point 133
-
Regulation 2907/77
-N : point 135
-
Decision 97/430
: point 13
-
Decision 2000/384
: point 13
-
Commission - Other Acts - 52001XC1123(02)
: point 30
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -827/79
: point 118
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -218/83
: points 73, 74, 83
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -12/86
: point 60
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -12/92
: point 78
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -432/92
: points 132, 135 - 137
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -153/94
: point 80
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -162/96
: point 60
-
Court of Justice - Judgment C -23/04
: points 75, 79
-
Written Parliamentary question - 92000E002747
: point 113
Dates
Date of the lodging of the application initiating proceedings
Date of the Opinion
Date of the hearing
Information not available
Date of delivery
25/02/2010
References
Publication in the Official Journal
Application: OJ C 285 from 08.11.2008, p.26
Judgment: OJ C 100 from 17.04.2010, p.4
Name of the parties
Brita
Notes on Academic Writings
- Simon, Denys: Interprétation des accords d'association euroméditerranéens CE/Israël et CE/OLP, Europe 2010 Avril Comm. nº 130 p.12-13 (FR)
- Kuijper, Pieter Jan: Case C-386/08, Brita GmbH v. Hauptzollamt Hamburg-Hafen Judgment of the European Court of Justice of 25 February 2010, Legal Issues of Economic Integration 2010 p.241-251 (EN)
- Harpaz, Guy ; Rubinson, Eyal: The Interface between Trade, Law and Politics and the Erosion of Normative Power Europe: Comment on Brita, European Law Review 2010 p.551-570 (EN)
- Cortés Martín, José Manuel: Jurisprudencia del Tribunal de Justicia de la Uníon Europea, Enero - Abril 2010, Revista de Derecho Comunitario Europeo 2010 nº 34 p.1-61 (ES)
- Martines, Francesca: Norme sull'origine dei prodotti e applicazione territoriale dell'Accordo di Associazione con Israele al vaglio della Corte di giustizia, Studi sull'integrazione europea 2010 nº 3 p.691-715 (IT)
- Díez Peralta, Eva: ’Made in Israel’: reflexiones en torno al etiquetado de mercancías fabricadas en los territorios palestinos ocupados. A propósito de la sentencia Brita del TJUE, de 25 de febrero de 2010 (C-386/08), Revista General de Derecho Europeo 2010, nº 21, p. 1-35 (ES)
- Puccio, Laura: Understanding EU Practice in Bilateral Free-trade Agreements: Brita and Preferential Rules of Origin in International Law, European Law Review 2011 p.124-134 (EN)
- Cardwell, Paul James: Adjudicating on the Origin of Products from Israel and the West Bank: Brita GmbH v. Hauptzollamt Hamburg-Hafen (C-386/08), European Public Law 2011 Vol. 17 Issue 1 p.37-50 (EN)
- Holdgaard, Rass ; Spiermann, Ole: Case C-386/08, Brita GmbH v. Hauptzollamt Hamburg-Hafen, Judgment of the Court of Justice (Fourth Chamber) of 25 February 2010, Common Market Law Review 2011 Vol.48 nº 5 p.1667-1685 (EN)
- Guarino, Giancarlo: Il territorio della Palestina, alla luce della sentenza della CGUE Brita GmbH, Atti del convegno in memoria di Luigi Sico. 2011 (Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II) 2011 p. 691-717 (IT)
- Fornari, Matteo: La Cour de Justice de l'Union Européenne se prononce sur l'importation de produits fabriqués dans les territoires palestiniens occupés: verre demi plein ou verre demi vide?, International Courts and the Development of International Law (Ed. T.M.C. Asser Press - Den Haag) 2013 p.897-910 (FR)
- Simon, Denys: Applicabilité des accords entre l'Union européenne et le Royaume du Maroc au territoire du Sahara occidental: Acte II, Europe 2018 avril nº 4 p.6-10 (FR)
Procedural Analysis Information
Source of the question referred for a preliminary ruling
Finanzgericht Hamburg - Germany
Subject-matter
- External relations
- - Association Agreement
- Free movement of goods
- - Customs union
Provisions of national law referred to
Information not available
Provisions of international law referred to
Information not available
Procedure and result
- Reference for a preliminary ruling
Formation of the Court
quatrième chambre (Cour)
Judge-Rapporteur
Malenovský
Advocate General
Bot
Language(s) of the Case
Language(s) of the Opinion