Reference for a preliminary ruling from County Court at Birkenhead (United Kingdom) made on 30 December 2020 – BT v Seguros Catalana Occidente, EB
(Case C-708/20)
Language of the case: English
Referring court
County Court at Birkenhead
Parties to the main proceedings
Applicant: BT
Defendants: Seguros Catalana Occidente, EB
Questions referred
Is it a requirement of Article 13(3) of the Judgments Regulation (EC) No. 1215/20121 that the cause of action on which the injured party relies in asserting a claim against the policy holder/insured involves a matter relating to insurance?
If the answer to (a) is ‘yes’, is the fact that the claim which the injured party seeks to bring against the policy holder/insured arises out of the same facts as, and is being brought in the same action as the direct claim brought against the insurer sufficient to justify a conclusion that the injured party’s claim is a matter relating to insurance even though the cause of action between the injured party and the policy holder/insured is unrelated to insurance?
Further and alternatively, if the answer to (a) is ‘yes’, is the fact that there is a dispute between the insurer and injured party concerning the validity or effect of the insurance policy sufficient to justify a conclusion that the injured party’s claim is a matter relating to insurance?
If the answer to (a) is ‘no’, is it sufficient that the joining of the policy holder/insured to the direct action against the insurer is permitted by the law governing the direct action against the insurer?
____________
1 Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 December 2012 on jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial mattersOJ 2012, L 351, p. 1